Generally, defense is a challenge because you have to manage all the players at one time. If I say nothing, we might default to the kind of wayward defensive tactics that begin to resemble offensive tactics. Tactics that only Civil War Commander William Tecumseh Sherman and his horrific “March to the Sea” approach could appreciate (then again, he later did declare that “War is Hell”).
Base running is a little more straightforward, even though it can create moments I have never seen or imagined before in my life. The other day, we had three runners on third at the same time. After first trying to sort it out, I thought, “No big deal, let me see what happens when the hitter puts the ball in play.” So he did, and two out of the three ran home. Not bad. (Since we don’t keep score, I didn’t have to explain to some stats department how someone knocked in two runs with both runners starting from third base.) I was never clear how I would have scored the runner who elected to stay — who essentially got lapped, since he was the first runner to get to third — but I will figure it out before our next game.
In fairness to this brand of baseball, the basic rules are different. No outs or runs are really recorded; everyone in the lineup hits; every hit is a single; and coaches pitch against their own team. Oh, and forget about the pace-of-game rules that major league baseball implemented this season to speed things up: our game the other night whipped through two innings in two hours. Somewhere, I heard Rob Manfred, the commissioner of Major League Baseball and the architect of “speed-up rules,” scream in horror.
I had been warned about the nuanced challenges of coaching your own children. Not a straightforward exercise. The day of our opening game was cold, and who was the player kneeling, mid-inning, in deep right field wearing rain boots and a jacket over his uniform, hands in his pocket and hatless? My son. This does not jibe with my rule to “always be in an athletic position” on defense. The scouting report on my son is as follows: Nice swing, good hustle, highly competitive, reads books with teammate’s sister between innings, intolerant of the cold or frivolous rules (all rules are frivolous).
My daughter, who is also on the team, has two primary concerns: When are we going to get a drink of water and when can she steal a base (the latter strikes me as purely hypothetical). But I like her thinking here. Scouting report: Great mechanics, fast learner, fast runner, needs to adjust the location of her swing to make more contact, always thirsty, literally.
At times, as we try to bring along our pure rookies, I do feel for the kids who were weaned on baseball and actually understand some of the game. Our shortstop/second base combo is like having the Red Sox’ Bogaerts and Pedroia. They are serious, they know the rules, they came dressed in full Red Sox regalia during our two-day “spring training.” So when a teammate “spiked” the ball on first base, thinking this was how to record an out, the Bogaerts half of my double play tandem was perplexed.
“This is his first game, he is learning,” I explained. He said, “O.K., no problem, I understand.”
I applauded his willingness to help others learn the game, and then I appointed him player-coach. He’s 6. I will pay him in sunflower seeds.